Castrol Cricket : ExpertFanSpeak
 
Remember me on this computer
Forgot your password? click here!
 
Not a member yet?
Castrol India
 
 
Expert Fan Speak

ARE YOU A CRICKET FAN? PLEASE JOIN OUR CONVERSATION!

Expert Fan Speak puts you in the spotlight where you have deep conversations about cricket, with other expert fans. Ask insightful questions, give meaningful answers - just discuss the game! And for a limited time, get paid for it!! Learn more about the Hall of Fame Competition!

 
 
QUESTION OF THE WEEK
 
 
The recently concluded Tri Series was a revelation of sorts as Dhoni's captaincy was found wanting when he had limited resources at his disposal. Captaincy skills will matter when Dhoni has to lead a younger side. This is where the true grit of Captain cool will be on display. As a captain ,how does Dhoni evolve when he has to lead a younger side?
 
 
Asked by SUNIL MELWANI · 5 Answers
 
   
   
 
 
 
 
ANSWER OF THE WEEK
 
There is a great sense of urgency worldwide to save test cricket, the traditional format of the game...
Any religious follower of the game of cricket would agree to the fact that test cricket is the mother of all forms of the game. There might be ODI, T-20 and even T-10, but the essence of test cricket is unmatched by any other form of the game. If you think that sticking to one format like T-20 will make the game more popular globally, the uniqueness of the game would be lost. Cricket can't be like football. It's an altogether different ball game. While a player's skills, fitness and stamina are tested over a period of five days (may be four days in the near future) in test cricket, in football, it's a matter of 90 minutes to 120 minutes. T-20 may be drawing more crowds and filling up the coffers of many cricket boards, but test cricket will always be near and dear in all the players' hearts and earning a test cap for the country is still considered the highest achievemnent by a cricketer. Also, if you take into account the scores of cricketers who have played for their respective countries, only those who are into test cricket have had long careers at the highest level. As far as ODI specialists are concerned, one bad series and they find themselves out of the team. The only way they can make a comeback is by performing well at the domestic level, which, again, will be three-day or four-day fixtures. Whatever way you look at it, test cricket is still very much the king and all those efforts going in to save the format is vry much worth it and it's our duty as well.
Answered by Srinath H. R.
People are seriously thinking about who would play at No 7 for India in the forthcoming World Cup 20...
Let the things be simple and don't make the issue as hypothetical and complex. As per my understanding by watching cricket, pick the best specialist batsmen bowler spinner and wicketkeeper. When out top specialist six batsmen perform decently the role of the seventh eighth doesn't arise at all friends. We Indian are very passionate and hence circumspect of the situation. When top batsmen doesn't do there job and win for India what can the other can. Hence we shouldn't be complaining about it and expect the best specialist in form who can deliver at tough times should be selected to get us till semi final of 2011 world cup. Job is done rest is lottery for all the four teams. If I get the luxury of selecting the best batsmen the list would be like Sehwag, Gambhir, Sachin, Youvraj, Suresh Raina, Robin Uthappa, Badrinath, Rohit Sharma, Virath Kohli. Dhoni being the captain selects himself. These are the specialist experienced and attitude hence having a all rounder in the team doesn't requires at all. Fully fit bowlers having right attitude should be selected like Ashish Nehra, Praveen, I Sharma, Amit mishra, Ojha, Harbajan
Answered by SHAILENDRA
 
 
 
 
 
 
Ask any cricket question
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Be the first one to answer
 
 
Who will be 2010 T20 world Champ?
 
 
 
 
COMMENTED BY CI EDITOR< COMMENTED BY EDITOR
 
 
QUESTION OF THE DAY
 
 
The harsh truth is that cricket betting is here to stay. But a lot of innocent betters lose because of bookies who fix bets. Has the time come for Cricket Betting to be legalised?
 
 
Asked by SUNIL MELWANI · 0 Answers
 
   
   
 
 
 
Answer of the day
 
 
Could corruption in cricket taken place had every player been paid with justification. When a player...
 
 
The game of cricket is no more a simple game between bat and ball. It is now between bets and bookies. When a player is offered money, most often he will refuse it. But Pakistan is being isolated from cricket and this will definitely influence the mind. If a player is tempted to make more money from off-the field, chaos does stray in. Look what happened to our own Sreesanth. He may not have strayed into the nether world but he got more popular and he made money from endorsements. His game did get affected but he was still making money. This is what money does. In the past players truly played for the country. But look at the recent trend. Players announce their retirements but do not mind playing the IPL. Would the IPL have been successful had it not offered such fantastic money. Because of the sheer bucks, it has become a winner. Its not about pure cricket but more about a financial venture. Laws have been tweaked and they are not true to the original spirit of the game. In recent times, cricket is the rare sport which keeps changing its laws. Even football,tennis and golf are still played with the old rules. These games are still based on pure skills. Cricket has been altered and we have players becoming superstars before they become true blue players. Money has changed the equation and we have to admit it. Sachin Tendulkar said T20 was for the younger crowd and skipped the World Cup. But he played in the IPL. Had Sachin chosen to board the flight to the T20 World Cup in the Windies, India would have surely performed better. But this is all a theory but one thing about loyalty is it has changed. Runs may make you a star but if one is not paid, will a cricket player remain honest. In the IPL we even had semi-injured players taking to the field. Injuries are hidden and manipulated. Damage does occur but does anyone really care. Dhoni complains of too much cricket but this is not the truth. If the IPL went on for 2 months, no player would complain. Values have changed. Its all about changing economics and choices. Test Cricket is the real thing but sadly it is played to empty stands. People want 6's but do not appreciate the class of a Dravid. Cricket has evolved and we need to introspect.
 
 
Answered by PRAMILA CHIRUKANDAN
 
 
Leader Board
Match Center
What Is Castrol Index
Harsha Bhogle

The Castrol Index objectively analyses and ranks player and team performances adopting a comprehensive approach towards the game. Harsha Bhogle explains how Castrol Index works.

What Is Castrol Index